Why critical infrastructure must be redesigned with disruption in mind

Mike Sewart, CTO at Thales UK, on how to secure the critical systems underpinning modern digital society.

Share
Today's economy is frighteningly reliant on technology built for a world that no longer exists (Image: Unsplash)
Today's economy is frighteningly reliant on technology built for a world that no longer exists (Image: Unsplash)

The vulnerability of our world to cyber risk is increasingly difficult to ignore. In recent weeks, supermarkets across Europe grappled with the impact of a cyber attack that left food in fridges and freezers thawing, while vulnerabilities in the database language PHP identified with proof of concept exploits developed by AI saw websites around the world taken offline.

The emergence of AI acts as a force multiplier to building, experimenting and launching cyber attacks, and our digital systems face the prospect of threats at a scale and speed previously impossible.

In the context of our energy, utility, and other critical infrastructure, this risk is particularly acute. Much of this infrastructure was never designed to be connected to the Internet, and with many having a lifespan measured in years and decades, it leaves the key infrastructure underpinning our grid dangerously exposed. AI is letting adversaries move quickly, and it is becoming difficult for those defending infrastructure to keep up.

The traditional OT (Operational Technology) systems that control physical machinery for critical infrastructure have steadily been further embedded with technology to meet a range of efficiency and control needs.

Cloud platforms, connected sensors, software, remote access and third-party suppliers all now play some role in the ongoing operation of these assets, and it means critical infrastructure operators now must ensure their approach to security is shifting to accommodate this new reality. 

Upgrading security alongside capacity

At the same time, our electricity grid is set to undergo significant changes to better link supply to demand. Current constraints on the network mean that renewable energy resources are being underutilised at a cost to the taxpayer of billions. As the UK Government seeks to address this mismatch by investing in long-term upgrades to our transmission network, it is essential that cyber resilience is built in from the outset. 

Thales’ latest Data Threat Report gives some indication of how the cyber risk in these environments has shifted. Among critical infrastructure organisations, IoT is now the leading attack target, identified by 46% of respondents, followed by cloud storage at 44% and cloud infrastructure at 40%.

Balancing access with visibility

Protecting our critical infrastructure now means understanding not just the physical footprints and operational aspects of our electricity grid, but building security and resilience into the underlying digital capabilities these assets depend on. A significant part of this challenge lies in knowing exactly who – or what – has access to sensitive systems and data. 

As operational environments change, individual identities may belong to an employee, an engineer connecting remotely, or a supplier, as well as increasingly IoT, sensor and machine identities too. Each requires legitimate access to keep the service operating, but with that access remaining appropriate, understood and controlled.

This need is a growing one, with 66% of critical infrastructure organisations surveyed for Thales’ Data Threat Report saying credential theft and misappropriated secrets is a growing problem they’re observing. Robust measures are needed to store and prevent the theft of legitimate credentials, as well as attempts by malicious actors to impersonate someone else. It underscores the importance of identity and access being seen as operational issues as much as security ones. 

As critical infrastructure operators face up to the reality of cyber threats conducted at machine speed, it raises new questions around how we approach resilience in the first place. Historically, we’ve worked to detect and stop attacks before they happen, but as AI changes the game, perhaps there are lessons we can learn from engineering here – namely can the service continue operating safely if something goes wrong? 

Built-in redundancy

If a conventional IT device is compromised, disconnecting or powering it down might be an obvious response, but industrial environments don’t have this option. The priority must be to build in ways that physical processes can keep running even during disruption – with systems that are secure, safe and resilient by design, rather than added as an afterthought.  

One way this can be achieved is by building and maintaining backup systems that can be spun up should the most critical systems go offline, which are in turn physically separated from the rest of the infrastructure.

Segmenting operational networks is another way that operators can improve resiliency, by making it more difficult for attackers to move about within a system should they gain access. With no single point of failure for the whole system, building in redundancy allows for the likely scenario of sections falling offline. 

READ MORE: Ancient UK water systems face a modern security threat that's worrying business leaders

Alongside technologies comes behaviour and policies. CNI needs expert engineers and operators that understand systems’ dependencies on each other, and can quickly react when disruption occurs so that systems can evolve with the threat.

At Thales’ cyber resilience facility in Ebbw Vale, we can test different approaches, technologies and responses in representative operational environments with engineers and cyber specialists – rehearsing incidents without putting live infrastructure at risk. 

As the UK embarks on some of the largest upgrades to the electricity grid in a generation, the goal must be systems that not only have the flexibility and efficiency demanded today, but are in the strongest possible position to evolve with the cyber threats of the future, absorb disruption and continue delivering essential service.  

Follow Machine on LinkedIn